Friday, April 20, 2012

Perinatal choices: Where to birthe

Thanks for sticking around to read the second installment in our "Perinatal Choices" series.  This time, I'm writing about choosing a birth setting that is right for your family.

I've been trying to look for the source of a pithy quote I heard a while ago comparing the environment for labor and sex, but I haven't been able to find it...so I'm going to quit searching for it and just paraphrase.  It goes something like...

A good labor requires the same kind of setting as is necessary for a good intimate experience:
love,
safety,
and privacy.

A beautiful sentiment that I think is so true.  Choosing a setting for birth that aligns with these ideals is something specific for a laboring woman and her family.  For many, it is a simple decision.  For others, it requires delicately balancing the three elements that makes a beautiful birth.

Popular practice
To quote the 2008 Milbank Report on Evidence-based Maternity Care:
Childbearing is a major life passage for over 4.3 million mothers, newborns, and families annually in the United States. Within the U.S. health care system, childbirth is the leading reason for hospitalization. About 23 percent of all individuals discharged from hospitals are mothers or newborns. The current style of maternity care is procedure-intensive, and six of the fifteen most commonly performed hospital procedures in the entire population are associated with childbirth. Cesarean section is the most common operating room procedure in the country. Only three reasons for outpatient visits involve more visits annually than maternity care (prenatal and postpartum visits combined): general medical examination, progress visit, and cough.
Evidently, birth is a big deal...but it could be simpler than the complicated mess we've made it out to be.  So let's find you a place that works out best for your family.

So, what are our options?  Hospital, birth center, or home.  Let's look at these options individually:

Hospital
As mentioned in the last post and evidenced by the above quote from the Milbank report, this is by far the most popular option in the U.S.  For women whose pregnancy and impending births are considered to be "high risk" (e.g., pre-eclampsia, baby has a congenital heart problem, severe oligohydramnios, etc.) it is most likely that they are recommended a hospital birth.  That makes good sense.

There are other cases where a woman, under the care of midwives, was planning to give birth at home or at a birth center but she and/or the newborn is determined to need higher level care, she would also go into the hospital.  That also makes good sense.

But normal birth hasn't always taken place in the hospital.  When did this change happen?  In 1900, less than 5% of American women gave birth in hospitals.  At the turn of the century was when a whole slew of events took place to sway more families into giving birth in the hospital setting.  These events included:
  • better roads, which made the trek to the hospital easier
  • employee medical programs were established, incentivizing the use of licensed medical professionals and hospital facilities
  • the "twilight sleep" birthing trend became popular and women [who could afford it] thought, "If I could do this without pain, heck, what's stopping me?!"
  • poor public hygiene due to overcrowding made the home a less favorable environment for birth and this caused the rate of infant and maternal mortality to rise
  • the American Medical Association grew in size and power in the political arena
...just to name a few.

With upper class women heading the movement of hospital births, their less financially fortunate counterparts see the trend as being a positive thing. The same kind of thinking applies to the trend shifts for breastfeeding (i.e., the use of wet nurses and the eventual use of formula). Furthermore, these trends are not only contained in the West, but are also perpetuated through colonialism. Even though the imperialism era is considered "over," we continue to see some of these practices (e.g., hospital births, routine episiotomies, lithotomy positions, routine cleaning of the uterine cavity during a Cesarean section, etc.) in areas affected by colonialism long after colonists have moved out of the area.

As an aside, I have heard that labor and delivery units in hospitals receive the most funding to "make things pretty and pleasant" because studies have found that moms are usually responsible for making decisions regarding health and where to go for care.  So if moms have a good experience during birth at a certain hospital, they are more likely to choose that facility as a care place for their whole family.  Interesting, huh?  Lots o' money to be made, m'friends!

Anyhow, to summarize, we can look at some of the pros & cons of hospital births:

Pros:
  • "If something goes wrong, the most advanced help is readily available."
  • Staff ready for normal and complicated/high-risk births.
  • More options for pain management
  • Insurance more likely to cover hospital births than births in other settings.
Cons:
  • "If something goes wrong, it was probably the hospital-based interventions that caused it."
  • Higher likelihood of continuous monitoring and interventions (e.g., augmentation of labor by pitocin, forceps, etc.)
  • Requires travel from home
  • Because of the high number of healthcare staff present (OBs, L&D nurses, baby nurses, students, etc.), family's wishes may not be honored because of convoluted communication.
  • If you give birth in a teaching hospital, you'd better believe your vajayjay is going to be poked and prodded by lots and lots of strangers.
Birth center
If you want to give birth in a peaceful, home-like environment but don't want to wash the placenta remnants out of your bedsheets, a birth center might be a good option for you.  All birth centers come equipped with IV fluids, isolettes with a warming mechanism for newborns, resuscitation equipment, and most will have glorious, glorious bath tubs for your labor.  (You can read more here about the Washington State requirements for the equipment and supplies that a birthing center must have.)
Birth certificate data on nearly 2.3 million singleton births in 2008 in the United States showed that about 10,700 women, or less than 1 percent (0.47 percent), delivered in a birthing center, usually a standalone facility staffed by a midwife and in close proximity to a hospital in case of emergency. The number of birth center births and home births in the U.S. in recent years are pretty comparable. 

A growing trend these days is birth centers that exist within a hospital.  Do you know what these birth centers were called before?  Uh, maternity wards.  That's right.  But because of more evidence/marketing data showing that women feel better with a big ol' laboring tub and less interventions, hospitals are shifting the way their maternity wards operate.  Some of the things that qualify a labor & delivery department in a hospital to be called a "birthing center" could include queen-size beds, jacuzzi tubs, maybe some sort of separation from the rest of the sick part of the hospital, and a large midwifery practice.

Onto the pros and cons of birth centers:

Pros:

  • Without health insurance, costs less than hospital birth.
  • Less interventions than hospital setting and more freedom in moving around during labor and even birth.
  • You can choose who attends the birth (including children).
  • No need to do the laundry. :)
  • So, did I already mention awesome bathtubs?
Cons:
  • Requires travel from home. And after you have given birth, you can only typically stay for 4-6 hours (which is usually not a problem with most families).
  • In case of an emergency, delays caused by the transport might prove to be costly.
  • Less options for pain management.  Your midwife can offer IV pain killers but no epidural.
  • Insurance may not cover it.
Home
The same 2008 study with singleton births as cited above in the birth center section found 12,400 women (0.54 percent) gave birth at home intentionally.  This number has been rising by nearly 30 percent in recent years.  Nonetheless, home births in the U.S. is still a very controversial topic.  Listen to these discussions between Ricki Lake and the cast of The Doctors.
 Part 1

Part 2
*shudder*

[I know many of my friends watch this show.  But my humble opinion is that The Doctors sucks on many, many levels...beginning with evidence-based practice vs. opulence-inspired health.  Anyway...]

More controversial yet is the movement of unassisted home births.  Unassisted home birth is exactly as it sounds: birth at home without the assistance of any trained professionals. This topic is controversial because birth without assistance not only puts mom at risk but also the fetus/newborn.  If complications arise, a lay person who's in that chaotic birthing time may not have the capacity to get help in time.

But just the idea of home birth is squeamish to many Americans.  We allow Hollywood to educate us on the practice of home birth and birth in general...like in this recent movie, The Backup Plan, for instance.  I wonder if the movie was funded by ACOG.

Anyhow, pros & cons of home birth:
Pros:
  • No need to leave home and risk shifting the flow of labor. And once you're done, you're already home!
  • Without health insurance, home births cost the least out of the three options.
  • Least amount of intervention.
  • There is a lot of freedom in moving around in labor (no continuous monitoring), you can eat and drink freely, and you can choose who attends the birth (including children).
  • Most home birth midwives are cool with water births.  If giving birth in a hospital setting (or even some birthing centers), water births are often not allowed due to the pediatric team's discomfort with the idea of baby being born into water.
  • If your home is decently clean, chances are you have a much lower risk of infection giving birth there as compared to at a hospital environment.  The hospital is where sick people go!
Cons:
  • Requires a decently clean environment...and you'd have to do the laundry. Doh!
  • In case of an emergency, delays caused by the transport might prove to be costly.
  • You have a smaller team of care providers with you (one midwife, possibly two, and hopefully a doula).  It is crucial that they know what the heck they're doing in the case of an emergency.  If the main midwife in charge is clueless, you are not in an environment where there could be a quick turnaround in getting other experienced staff involved.
  • Even less options for pain management.
  • Not all insurance plans will cover home births.
The evidence
A 2003 study of nearly 3,000 birth center births versus hospital births found that not only did both places resulted in equally safe outcomes for both mothers and babies, but the women who gave birth in birth centers wound up with fewer epidurals and cesareans (each having varying high rates of associated complications).

A more recent study found that babies born at home have a higher risk of complications, including lower Apgar scores, unless the birth was attended by a Certified Nurse Midwife.  Being trained as both a nurse and a midwife, these professionals have a well-rounded knowledge of medicine as well as the science of birth to equip them for dealing with emergent situations.  This study also found that birth outcomes were similar for babies born at the hospital as compared to birthing centers.

In general, however, I have found that it is difficult to track down an honestly good research study to fairly compare birth in these three settings.  Data is often convoluted with home births that were not intentional, those that were unassisted, c-section rates that do not appropriately attribute emergent home/birthing center transfers, etc.



The documentary Business of Being Born was when I first heard the phrase "cascade of intervention." Take a look:


Changing into the hospital gown
Putting on the hospital gown shifts the balance of power from woman to hospital.  Her perception of herself shifts, and she sees herself as a patient, in the care of “experts,” rather than as a woman confident in her ability to birth on her own terms. This simple act may also make the woman feel less comfortable, feel cold or she may be concerned about modesty as well, which increases stress and makes relaxation harder.

Continuous Electronic Fetal Monitoring (EFM)
The major effect  of continuous EFM is that it keeps the mother immobile in bed. The use of EFM is not evidence-based, and has had no effect in improving outcomes for babies.  Evidence shows that Intermittent EFM with a handheld Doppler is just as effective as continuous EFM at identifying babies in distress.  The only effect continuous EFM has had is that it has increased the cesarean section rate.

Getting the IV
IV’s restrict a woman’s mobility and make it easier to administer fluids and medications that interfere with natural birth.  Women need to be free to move their bodies throughout labor, and should be encouraged to change positions frequently.  Having an IV can hinder that. The IV is also simply uncomfortable, annoying and may interfere with her focus on relaxing with contractions as well and make holding hands with her support person more uncomfortable or impossible. Even a hep lock can be bothersome in the same ways. The perception that having an IV readily available is helpful in an emergency is not evidence based. Many times this IV port is not working well enough to handle an emergency and must be restarted.

Labor augmentation with Pitocin®
The use of synthetic oxytocin (Pitocin®) makes labor more painful for the mother, and more difficult for the baby to tolerate. There are studies that show pitocin may interfer with the body's natural ocytocin hormone production which may hinder the mother's natural efforts in the pushing stage, may contribute to postpartum hemorrhage and may interupt her bonding with her baby, contributing to postpartum depression. http://www.birthresourcenetwork.org/resources/54-pitocin-the-whole-story-

Pain relief
Because the contractions are so intense with Pitocin®, the mother frequently will choose to receive an epidural for pain relief.

Restriction of movement
An epidural keeps a woman confined to bed for the duration of the labor and birth.  Being unable to move restricts the woman’s ability to help her baby get into a good position for birth. It may also hinder the baby's ability to move, too.

Contractions slow down
Epidurals can slow labor progress, which results in increasing dosages of Pitocin® to increase contraction intensity and frequency, which can lead to an even greater need for pain relief and greater risk of fetal distress.

Progress slows or stops
Assuming the woman reaches full dilation, the epidural can interfere with the woman’s ability to push effectively.

Fetal distress
Hard contractions, combined with reduced blood pressure and the lack of blood flow to the baby, cause the baby to go into distress.

Cesarean section
After having exhausted all of the tools at the obstetrician’s disposal, this one option remains.


From my experience in the labor & delivery departments of several area hospitals, I have seen this cascade far too many times.  It doesn't always end up in a C-section, but interventions are almost guaranteed in a hospital setting and when things go South, the phrase, "We need to do what is best for your baby" gets tossed around a lot...

As a final note, I want to point our attention to this number: 41.  That is the position the U.S. is in with the maternal mortality ranking.  This means that if you are giving birth in the top 40 countries, you have a better chance of surviving childbirth.  The CDC further states that many of the maternal deaths in the U.S. are completely preventable.
Does that make any sense?  How do we spend the most money and get such sh*tty outcomes?!

Our experience
We chose to have both Penelope and Camille (and eventually Marcus) at the Family Beginnings "Birthing Center" at Group Health Central in Seattle. In an effort to piss off a large number of people in one single shot, I have been heard comparing the choice of birthing at a birth center to buying a townhouse, using a hybrid cloth diaper, or driving a hybrid car.  And, ha!  I've bought a townhouse-ish condo, used hybrid cloth diapers, and recently bought a hybrid vehicle!  So, really, joke's on me. What I meant with the comment above is that birth centers serve as a safe compromise between hospital and home birth.  My criticism here is that sometimes these middle-ground compromises are neither satisfying nor are they the best option for you and your family.  Nonetheless, you need to make the decision that is best for your family.  And oftentimes that involves a lot of compromising.

For me, I would like to have a home birth.  As much as I like to go out, I am not a fan of traveling when I am in pain.  I like to be in a comfortable home environment where I know that nobody has C.diff or that a colostomy bag had busted just down the hall.  A friend of mine (who is now a Certified Nurse Midwife) once said that she would like to have a home birth because that is where she knows she has no option for an epidural, which she is well aware is associated with many complications.  Another reason for a home birth is that after I gave birth to Camille in the hospital, I was given a UTI by a not-so-careful nurse who failed to catheterized me in a sterile manner.  This wouldn't have happened at home...where I think I would feel more naturally in my element and in control of the situation so that I could refuse unnecessary procedures.

Chin is less keen with the idea of a home birth because of the "just in case sh*t happens" scenario.  

I get that.  I'm pretty cautious, too.

"What if something unforeseen happens?  Like baby needs a lot more extra help."  We opted not to do any prenatal screening for genetic abnormalities (despite of, or perhaps because of, what happened with Penelope).  So what if baby has some strange complication that we weren't aware of?  What if I run a high fever and need an immediate administration of an IV antibiotic?  I don't want to be transferred!  Not all of these concerns are rational, but they are feelings...which are not always based on logic but are valid all the same.

As kind of an aside, one thing to consider if you are giving birth in the hospital is what kind of care is available should your newborn require special medical attention.  There are three types of nurseries available:
  • Level 1 nursery - This is the nursery you see in the olden days where nurses will swoop in to save the pooped-out parents by taking the healthy newborn away for a number of hours during the postpartum period.  The overwhelming evidence for better outcomes in rooming-in has more or less made these simple type of nurseries obsolete.
  • Level 2 nursery - aka progressive or special care nursery (PCN/SCN).  Instead of having a full-on neonatal intensive care unit (NICU), some hospitals only have a Level 2 nursery where they can take care of mildly complicated cases.  Here, babies can be given supplementary oxygen, be tube-fed, and receive some IV therapy.
  • Level 3 nursery - aka a NICU. A NICU is equipped to take care of basically all your little baby problems from needing sugar water to being on a ventilator.
If you know before hand that your baby will require special attention after birth, you will most likely need to give birth in a setting that has an adjoining NICU.  If you just like to be super safe or tend to freak out in general, you will probably want to give birth in a setting that has an adjoining NICU.  So, check with your hospital.

Anyway...

Weighing our pros and cons, we decided to give birth at the Group Health Central birth center because:
  • Our insurance will fully cover it. (Since Marcus will be born in 2012, our insurance will still cover everything at 100% and does not require a co-pay.  After 2012, all bets are off.)
  • Our families would flip if they hear that their grandchild was born somewhere outside of a hospital.  And the headache that would cause is not worth it for us.
  • We are working with a fantastic team of midwives who we trust and who we believe will honor our wishes.
  • We are educated individuals and we are [mostly] aware of our rights, options, and the evidence behind perinatal practices.  Should something come up in the hospital setting where we felt like we are strong-armed, we fully know we are the health care consumers and we are the ones ultimately making the decision.  (Easier imagined in theory, I think.)
Thrilled

My opinion is that when we choose the care provider or setting for birth, too many women and families operate out of fear instead of rationally thinking through the evidence.  We are already irrational beings to begin with.  Throw in birth hormones and family pressure and pain...and we are a mess!  It's a very vulnerable time, really.  Which is not surprising that when the sacred bubble of this birthing experience is breached, some women refer to it as "birth rape."

My best advice to those who are trying to choose a birth setting: choose a provider/group of providers that you trust.  I think it is paramount that in this vulnerable scenario, women are surrounded by people who (1) know their stuff and (2) are truly supportive of her and her family.  From there, consider your options and, with the help of those you trust, make an informed decision about the birth setting that is the most ideal for your family.

I wish you the best birth!

Acknowledgements & Resources 

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

Amusing moments with Camille

Camille has been growing so fast.  What happened to this little baby?!

One month old

There have been so many funny and heart-warming Camille moments lately.  I feel that if I don't write them down somewhere, I'll forget.

Swiper from Dora the Explorer
Her language skills are amazing (to us, anyway).  She can count to 10 and knows 10 colors (black, white, brown, yellow, red, blue, green, purple, pink, and orange).  She is putting together sentences...and they're all to communicate something that she wants us to do for her (e.g., "I can't open it!" or "I eat gummy bears!" or "Nes ehsode!"...meaning "Next episode [of Dora the Explorer]" as a spoken command for the Xbox).

She is so enamored with Dora the Explorer.  While reading a story out of a Bible story book the other week, she pointed to the fox on the page (picture below) and said, "Swiper!" She then extended her short little arm and said, "Swiper, no swiping.  Swiper, no swiping.  Swiper, NO swiping!  Oh man!!!"


Fox from Bible story book


***

At pediatrician's office...  Pediatrician had just finished with checking her for a resolving cold and said, "Well, Miss Camille, how about we go get you some stickers?"

Camille was super excited and started going batsh*t crazy over the idea of stickers.  I tried to put her clothes back on (which was no easy task) and gather all of our stuff.

"Mommy!  Mommy!  Stickers!  Dora stickers!" she exclaimed.

I kept working on putting her shoes on.

"Mommy!  Mommy!!  MOM!"

I put on the other shoe.

"Bao!  Bao!  Bao Ng!"

W....T....F?!  How do you know my full name, kid?!

***

A bite out of every piece
Before nap time, I was changing her diaper and Camille said, "Mommy, I poop."  So off to the potty we went.  She sat there and sat there and played with her toys.

"Do you need to poop?" I asked.

"No," she responded.

"Do you at least need to pee?"

"Pee?  Yellow one?" *pees* "See?  I pee.  Yellow one."

Then she gets up from the potty and starts to walk around the bathroom.  She sees her toothbrushes and asked to brush her teeth (one of her favorite things to do).

"Brushing teeth is for early in the morning and before bed time, Camille.  But if you poop, I will let you brush your teeth."

Within 4 seconds, I kid you not, I see a poopy face...and my reaction time was definitely too slow.

[imagine this in slow motion] "N...o...o...o...o...o...o...!  Get...back...on...your...potty...chair!"  I reached out to her.

It was too late.

She had already pinched off two loaves on the bathroom floor.  Two soft lumps with black kiwi seeds.

"Brush teeth?" she asked.

***

Doing PT with BaBa
While I was at the store to get Chin's prescription today, Chin got to spend some quality time with Camille.

Camille points to her tummy and said, "Tummy!  Miu tummy."

"Does BaBa have a tummy?" Chin asked.

She points to Chin's tummy.

"Does Mommy have a tummy?" Chin asked.

"Yeah," she replied.

"What's inside Mommy's tummy?" he asked.

Camille stops to think about it and then shyly said, "Baby Marcus." :)


We love this little girl

Friday, April 13, 2012

Chestnut Week 27

*pop!*

This first week of 3rd trimester has been good, despite being very busy and living through Camille's first febrile episode.  (Yes, her first time mounting a full-on immune response that resulted in a fever!  I credit my boobs.)  Here are some pictures from this week...to make up for so many of the late belly pictures.

Camille has been eating better these days.
Weighed her at my midwife appointment on Wed
and she was 21.9 lbs...with clothes on!
Loves drawing with and sometimes eating crayons
Drawing with BaBa
"Cheeeeeeeese" (Easter 2012)
All dressed up in Mariner's uniform on opening day!
Chin & I got to go to the Mariner's game on opening day
at Safeco Field.  Thanks to Kristie for the tickets & thanks
to Sherwin & Mina for watching Camille!

Technically, this is what's going on this week:
  • Chestnut is as hefty as a head of cauliflower, - ~ 14.41 inches and 1.93 pounds.
  • His head is over 2.5 inches in diameter.
  • His hearing continues to develop.
  • His eyes can blink, open and close.
Physical:
  • Weight: 140 lb (+27)
  • Belly circumference: 38.5 in (+10)
  • Fundal height: 25.5 cm
  • I had a check up with my midwife this week and found that I had gained three pounds over the past week.  I'm not exactly sure how this happened...but I guess I should not be surprised because I am hungry all the time.  I have been more intentional about cutting down on carbs and controlling my portion.  It is tough.  And I can empathize with all of you who are trying to modify your behavior in any sort of way.  I just want to eat, eat, eat!
  • With Camille being sick this week and my school workload being a bit heavier, I've been averaging about 5 hours a night.  Chin captured a very typical picture of me these days: heavily gravid, sedentary, and tired.
*yaaaawn*
Spiritual & emotional:
  • Despite the busy-ness of school and home life, I am doing well.  The weather has been beautiful and I have been soaking it all in!
  • When I saw that I had gained 3 pounds this week, the thought of needing a c-section briefly entered my mind.  "What if Marcus is so big that I am too pooped to push him out?!"  It's a fear that may not be too unrealistic, eh?  Anyway, I know just need to calm the eff down, eat less, and exercise more.
  • I think I have reached this paradoxical/ambivalent stage in pregnancy where I am conflicted with the feeling of wanting baby to come soon (because I am tired of being pregnant) and not wanting baby to come soon (because I am not quite ready).  Regardless, I know that in my mind I want Marcus to stay in for as long as necessary.  So, hang out in there for a bit longer, Little Boy!  I love you!
Click here to see the comparison to my pregnancy with Camille (MacNut) at the same gestational age.

Friday, April 06, 2012

Perinatal choices: Choosing a provider

Sheesh!  You all know that I don't like to stress out and I choose not to.  But I was almost at the point of stressing out about writing this series.  "Where do I begin? When do I find time to write? What if the topics are all out of order? How do I maintain a readable length for each entry? Do I need to cite everything?!"

Then...

I decided to take a deep breath...

With that, I'd like to welcome you to the first segment of our discussion on perinatal* choices!  I'd like to keep things casual...but I am also a little anal about being systematic.  So I'm going to keep a consistent format of going over these headings:
  • Popular practice: What is an average American doing? What's common practice? What's the history behind these practices?
  • The evidence: According to research, what should be put in practice?  How do we compare to other countries?  Where are we in achieving the goals for health outcomes that we have set? What's stopping us from getting there?  How do we get there on the level of personal decision-making, telling others about the evidence, and integrating this into the broader healthcare systems?  (Okay, this is where I might go off because I seriously love what I do: bridging the gap between research and patient care delivery. But I hope that I don't spend too much time in this section as I think the next section is very important.)
  • Our experience: This is where I tell our story.  The best part, I think. :)
  • Acknowledgments & resources: Obviously I needed help putting this all together!  This is where I cite some of the key people and resources that helped me present this information.
So, with that, let's start talking about the first installment of the discussion on prenatal care choices: choosing a provider.  I'm going to warn you: it's a lonnnng blog post. :)

That Ryan Gosling, he really knows!

Popular practice
What are our options?  ObGyns or midwives.  Obstetricians are trained medical physicians with an "MD" after their names.  They have gone to school for many, many years and have learned to provide care for a wide range of pregnancies and birth situations including Cesarean sections.  Midwives come in a variety of different forms, but essentially they differ from ObGyns in that they typically care for uncomplicated pregnancies and assist vaginal births.

The difference between the two models of care are outlined below:

Midwifery Model of Care

Focus on health, wellness,
   prevention
Labor/birth as normal
   physiological processes
Lower rates of using
   interventions
Mother gives birth
Care is individualized

Medical Model of Care

Focus on managing problems
   and complications
Labor/birth as dependent on
   technology
Higher rates of using
   interventions
Doctor delivers baby
Care is routinized


Okay, okay, even though they claim to not be biased, I think the table above is pretty pro-midwifery.  Reading it with a grain of salt, please realize that there are plenty of OBs who are low-intervention and I have come across quite a few "medwives" out there, too.


So, who do we choose?  Most Americans choose ObGyns for prenatal care and birth. According to the 2006 National Center for Health Statistics, midwives attended 317,168 births - 7.4 percent of all births in the U.S. Of those births, 96.7% took place in hospitals, 2% in birth centers, and 1.3% at home.

Historically, midwives have attended births for thousands of years. Birth used to be an all-woman event where a laboring woman would be surrounded by female family members and at least one person who knows what the heck she's doing.  Then, somewhere along the way (I'm too lazy to look up exact dates), medical interventions such as Cesarean sections and forceps were introduced to help out complicated cases of labor.  And then there was the introduction of hardcore pain management such as morphine and chloroform in labor.  At the same time, general practitioners who wanted to gain a larger client base thought, "Hey, if I deliver this lady's baby, their whole family will come to me from now on for all their healthcare needs."  Around that point is where more and more women turn to the medical model for the management of their pregnancy and birth.

In the 60's and 70's in the U.S., there was then a counter movement against the medicalization of birth.  A few people said, "Eff this!" and started traveling around in buses, women didn't shave their armpits, and drugs were used in all settings except for birth.  They were considered "really weird."  But they did bring back a deep appreciation for the art of midwifery.

In the Pacific Northwest these days, evidence-based hippies as we are, there are still more women who choose to give birth in a hospital setting with obstetricians than those who choose any variety of midwives. 

The evidence
Have you heard of the Cochrane Collaboration or the Cochrane Library?  It is a collaboration that started out in the UK with the aim to find good, quality research on health and healthcare practices that can be brought back to the bedside.  In 1979, Dr. Archie Cochrane published an essay to draw attention to this need for randomized controlled trials in which he designated the field of obstetrics as the least scientific medical specialty. Ouch!


Just looking at our own backyard, birthing in the U.S., compared with other industrialized countries:
  • We are the most technology-oriented,
  • Spend the most $ per capita,
  • Largest % of birth attended by MDs,
  • Smallest % of birth attended by midwives,
  • Highest infant mortality rate (are you seeing this?!), and
  • Maternity mortality and morbidity rates are similar, too.
Alright, that's just data schmata.  It's not really sickening to you unless you were personally [and negatively] affected by it, right?

Well, if you are pregnant and you'd like to be well-informed about your care, this is a critical junction where you need to decide on a provider whose beliefs and practices align well with yours. It's fine to go with an obstetrician for your pregnancy and birth (complicated or not).  But if you haven't considered midwives as an option, it might benefit you to know that a recent review of 21 legit studies showed that births that are attended by midwives:
  • have comparable outcomes as those attended by OBs,
  • result in less interventions (e.g., episiotomy, labor induction, epidural analgesics),
  • have fewer incidence of perineal tearing, and
  • resulted in higher rates of breastfeeding.
There you have it.  There is a lot more evidence to show that care given by a midwife in pregnancy and labor is more cost-effective and result in more "peaceful" outcomes.  If you are interested, please let me know & I will send you those articles.

I feel that I can talk until I am blue in the face about evidence...but it doesn't impact the lives of people until it is relevant.  I am hoping that by telling our story and perspective, you could see the benefits of a less medicalized birthing experience.  So, read on!

Our experience
We went with a group of midwives from Neighborcare Health starting when I was pregnant with Penelope in the Spring of 2009.  I chose to go with midwives for a number of reasons:
  • I found them more personable,
  • the approach of these nurse midwives are both scientific and intimate,
  • I always felt that they were informing me of everything along the way,
  • and I have not met many OBs that I have felt very comfortable with.
Sam, the UW midwifery student who caught Camille
(with Chin's help, of course ;P)

A typical office visit with my midwife would start out with her asking, "How are you?"  I never felt rushed or brushed off.  When we found out that Penelope had many health complications, my midwife called me right away and checked in on how we were doing.  She asked, "Do you have people around who can cook and take care of household things for you during this time?"  I could not imagine any of the OBs I know to think of asking that!

With the Penelope's poor prognosis, the midwives suggested that we transferred our care to a group of perinatologists at a larger local hospital.  We tried them out.  Here is a quotable moment from the visit with that perinatologist:
Perinatologist [talking to Chin and ignoring me]: I think you should have a D&C.  I'm telling you right now that there is 0% chance your baby can live.  And there are many health complications that could affect your wife. If the baby dies in-utero, there are risks of infection.  She could have DIC.  She could have mirror syndrome.  Your wife could swell up like the Michelin Man!"
Me: I don't believe that mirror syndrome is very likely going to occur (I saw a case on House, MD - how prevalent could this disorder be if it was on House?!).  Sure, there are risks of complications but these are risks we are willing to take.  Please, just for the sake of our conversations going forward, assume that we do not want a D&C.
Perinatologist: Wow, you sound really smart.  Are you in the medical field?
Me: I'm just well-informed and I know what I want.
Perinatologist
: Because, most patients I work with would choose to terminate.  There is NO chance of survival.
Me: Please, doctor.  I don't want to discuss this anymore.
Perinatologist: Is it a religious thing?
Chin & me: [Utterly speechless.  Does it effin' matter, you moron?!]
There were several other things from that visit that made us question this doctor's level of competence.  At the end of the day, we called up our midwives and asked to be returned to their care.

Both Penelope and Camille were born under their care and we were very happy.  After moving to the Eastside and finding out that we were pregnant with Marcus (Chestnut) we considered other local options.  But after searching for a couple of months, Chin insisted that we go back to the Neighborcare midwives.  Even if this meant that I had to commute to South Seattle for prenatal checkups and we'd have to drive across the toll bridge to get to the hospital for birth.  (Yes, my husband is prepared to pay the toll.  That's how much we love and trust these midwives!)

There is a lot more of our story to come.  It'll just unfold as we delve further into this subject.  I hope you will read on because there is much more I'd like to share with you!

Acknowledgements & Resources
* Some of you (Chin) have inquired about the meaning of "perinatal."  "Peri" means "around" and "natal" means "birth."  So, around birth.

Chestnut Week 26


Today is the last day of the 2nd trimester.  Adios, 2nd trimester!  You didn't suck as much as 1st trimester, but you definitely weren't as glorious as I had hoped.  You know, I always thought I would love being pregnant.  Some days I do love it.  Most days...not so much.

That is the truth.

Aaaaand, friends, we have a name for Chestnut: Marcus!

I had a dream back in the Spring of 2009 (while I was pregnant with Penelope) that I had a little boy.  In the dream, I went to change his diaper and he projected an arc of pee onto my face.  Then he asked, "Mommy, what's my name again?"  I replied, "Your name is Marcus."  And he said, "Oh yeah, I forgot."

Now, I don't know any Marcus.  But Chin was playing a video game called Gears of War at the time and one of the main characters was Marcus Fenix.  Could it be that's how the name got into my head?  Perhaps.

"Let's do this, Marcus!"

Technically, this is what's going on this week:
  • Chestnut is as tall as an English cucumber - ~ 14.02 inches and 1.68 pounds.
  • His feet are 2 inches long. Hands are very active.
  • His eyes begin to open around this time.
  • The fetal brain scan will show response to touch. Touching and playing with the baby is possible now, as they may respond to your touch through your belly wall.
  • Baby is probably very active in the womb (very much!!), as the most active weeks are typically between weeks 24 and 28.
Physical:
  • Weight: 137 lb (+24)
  • Belly circumference: 38.25 in (+9.75)
  • I am the exact same weight and size as last week.  How could this be, especially after a period of rapid growth?  I think it is because for the first time in four weeks, this was the first week that I hadn't gone to a buffet.  Seriously.
  • I rub my belly all the time.  It's big and often in motion. :)
Spiritual & emotional:
  • I started taking 50,000 IU of Vitamin D once a week starting a couple of weeks ago and I feel a lot more alive.  My mood has been better!  It could also be that the weather is getting a bit sunnier, too.
  • School has been keeping me pretty busy.  For a couple of days, Camille didn't nap very well and this definitely cut into my studying time.  Very frustrating.  I had to stay up late those nights to do homework and I have been averaging 6 hours of sleep each night (no naps).  Pretty tiring.
  • To make up for her skipped naps, Camille had one massive day of sleep on Monday: she fell asleep on the way home from daycare (where she'd taken a 2-hour nap) and continued to sleep from 6pm until 8:30am the next day.  Chin & I enjoyed a pleasant dinner at home and I got a lot of homework done that day. :)
  • We are still in the process of looking for a long-term solution for childcare (starting now and continuing perhaps beyond my graduation).  This topic is on our mind a lot and we are just trusting that the Lord will give us wisdom in where to search for a good option.  Please pray for us.  Thank you!
Click here to see the comparison to my pregnancy with Camille (MacNut) at the same gestational age.

Saturday, March 31, 2012

Camille's 1st homestyled haircut

How do you cut a wriggly toddler's hair?

First, you take a "before" picture

Remove bath mats. Lay down butcher paper. Add crayons.

Add attentive and creative BaBa during styling process

Mommy, the stylist, and Camille

Final product!

Then bathe the wriggly toddler

"What...just...happened to all my hair?!"

Helping BaBa clean the vacuum cleaner.
(She is obsessed with Mommy's new boots!)

Her bangs are a little crooked.

Oh well, she is one happy & spirited gal nonetheless!

"Now, how 'bout you turn on some Elmo for me?"
That's how it's done!

Friday, March 30, 2012

Perinatal choices: A series

As the day of Chestnut's birth is drawing close, I can't help but reflect on my past birth stories.  Stories I embrace closely, delicately, and sacredly.  Many of have heard of Camille's glorious birth story and my subsequent reflection on that pregnancy/birthing/recovery experience.  Most of you may not have heard of Penelope's birth.

Penelope & Mommy

I started this blog post a few weeks or months ago...but haven't had the courage to publish it or start this series for a number of reasons:
  1. Time constraint - I'm busy.  But aren't we all?
  2. I'm honestly a little apprehensive about the backlash I might receive for some of these beliefs.
Okay, just those two reasons.

Last night, I had an opportunity to attend a class session with some midwifery friends at the UW School of Nursing - the program that I was originally admitted into prior to me "jumping ship" and switching over to family practice.  The class session was focused on evidence-based perinatal care.  Instead of a lecture, it was a casual discussion of the history and evidence on various topics surrounding birth.  Fascinating stuff!  For those who aren't very familiar with the field of midwifery, you might walk into the middle of our discussion and be amazed at how well-read these midwifery students were and how much they knew about the latest research (including how to appraise the trustworthiness of these studies).  Surprised?  You thought midwifery is a "soft" science?  Midwives are hardcore artists and hardcore scientists!  The reason that midwives must keep abreast of the latest evidence is that (1) they care about the well-being of women and families, and (2) they are constantly fighting an uphill battle.  They receive the lowest wages amongst advanced practice nurses, pay some of the highest rates for malpractice insurance, and are continually under the scrutiny of ACOG.

Anyhow, before I ramble on much further...  I want to start a series where I discuss some of the stories, news/blog articles, and evidence surrounding the subject of birth (which includes a little bit of pregnancy and newborn care, too).  Some of the topics that I will explore
  • Prenatal care:
    • Choosing a provider
    • Choosing a setting for birth -  home, birth center, and hospital
  • Labor:
    • NPO status - women not being allowed to eat during labor
    • Routine administration of IV fluids
    • Induction & augmentation of labor
    • Pain management
    • Continuous monitoring
    • Labor support (doulas)
  • Birth:
    • Birthing positions
    • Episiotomy
    • Assistive devices (forceps & vacuums)
    • C-sections (and VBAC)
  • Newborn care:
    • Suctioning of newborn
    • Timing of cord clamping
    • Skin-to-skin contact
    • Circumcision for male infants
    • Vaccination
    • Infant feeding practices
Before you may jump to the conclusion that I will do a lot of finger-wagging for the choices you have made for your family, please let me assure you that I will only present my story, the rationale for my choices, the evidence, and simply my own opinion.  I feel that this series is important for me to write because I deeply care about this subject and I hope that we can all stay informed about birth - an arena that has been viewed as taboo or, worse yet, left to Hollywood to educate the masses.

Yep, I'm in my undies. Obviously I don't care.

I know, I know, I previously attempted to start a series on reviews of baby products and then never ended up doing anything with it.  But this time, I'm gonna do it.

Seriously!  I will! :)

Chestnut Week 25

My pointy belly
 
We're very close to having a name.  Will discuss with grandparents and family first and then the name will be public. :)

Today, Chin & I celebrate the 12-year anniversary of our DTR'ing date (DTR = defining the relationship).  It has been a fantastic 12 years!

Technically, this is what's going on this week:
  • Chestnut is the size of a rutabaga - ~ 13.62 inches and 1.46 pounds.
  • Bones are becoming solid, hands are now fully developed. The structures of the spine begin to form - all 33 rings, 150 joints and 1000 ligaments.
  • The brain is growing rapidly, the brain cells are starting to mature.
  • Since the ear bones are hardening even more, baby's hearing is sharper. He is starting to recognize and remember parents' voices.
  • Baby's nostrils begin to open.
  • The sexual organs are fully developed.
  • The uterus is now about the size of a soccer ball and mom looks pregnant (or in my case, mom looks like she's pregnant with multiples!).
Physical:
  • Weight: 137 lb (+24)
  • Belly circumference: 38.25 in (+9.75)
  • I weighed myself at the clinic where I'm doing my rotation on Monday and I just about fell off the scale.  Seriously?!  I came home that day quite distraught and reported to Chin (in an almost weeping voice), "I can't believe I have gained this much weight.  My pre-pregnancy was 113 and now I'm freakin' 137 pounds!  So I have gained...what is that?  OMG, I can't even do math!!!"
  • I'm just hungry all...the...time. But now that I am more cognizant of my rapid weight gain, I am trying to cut down on carbs and increasing whole grains & fiber.
  • Little boy is kicking hard.  He is usually awake at night and kicks me whenever I try to take a nap or go down for the night.  I feel like Camille was more crazy with her kicks and was more active (although I have mentioned that this little boy is stronger).  When I mentioned this to my mother-in-law, she said, "Well, Bao, you are also older now."  I have no idea what that means.  Does that mean my senile uterus is less sensitive to kicks and rolls?  Or have I managed to produce an offspring from an older, weaker egg?  Hard to tell, really.
Spiritual & emotional:
  • First week back at school.  I'm very excited about this quarter!  I'll be doing my rotation at a diverse public health clinic, and two of my classes are about women's health.  It's going to be a good quarter.
  • Some things that pregnant women (myself included) don't like to hear:
    • "Do you think you might be a little too sensitive toward this issue?"  (Doesn't matter how you word-smith this question, it is wrong.)
    • "You're a lot less moody this week!" (Not a compliment.  Just makes me want to strangle you.)
    • "Are you sure you're not having twins?" (I want to stab you in the eyeball.)
  • You know that sense of tactfulness that one possesses and the self-restraint one has to refrain from saying things like, "Huh, ever wonder why you're single/broke/unemployed, moron?!" I'm starting to lose that.  Oh, of course there is the spiritual discourse of seasonality in singleness, poverty, and unemployment...but the perpetuity of it all and the striking correlation to idiocy does not escape me.  Some people are freakin' morons!
  • I'm a little saucy this week.
    Click here to see the comparison to my pregnancy with Camille (MacNut) at the same gestational age.

    Friday, March 23, 2012

    Chestnut Week 24

    This is my well-rested
    Spring Break look!

    Technically, this is what's going on this week:
    • Chestnut is the length of an ear of corn (*om nom nom nom*) - ~ 11.81 inches and 1.32 pounds.
    • He is now gaining around 3 ounces (90 grams) a week.
    • Taste buds begin to form. If mom drinks something strange or bitter, baby may be observed showing his distaste.
    • The eyelids can be seen very clearly.
    • Age of viability has been reached! If born at this stage, he has up to 85% chance of survival.
    Physical:
    • Weight: 132 lb (+19)
    • Belly circumference: 37.75 in (+9.25)
    • I normally have a hard time assessing fundal heights with my pregnancies, but this week I had a strong contraction and found that the fundus (top of uterus) is about 1 finger breadth above the umbilicus.  Does that make sense?  Well, I was laying flat on my back so maybe that makes a difference.  Anyway, I would hate to think that I am gaining lots of weight while my uterus is not growing as fast.  Speaking of which...
    • With my [pre-pregnancy] BMI being roughly 20, I should technically be gaining between 25-35 lbs during pregnancy.  Check out this graph I got from BabyCenter (which, by the way, I consider as barfalicious as What to Expect When You're Expecting, Babies-R-Us, Carter's brand, and the like)



      So, do you see that green dot?  That's where my weight is during week 24. The green dot is supposed to be between the two lines - the minimum and maximum recommended weight gain.  I'm only off by 1 pound.  I'm not too worried about it.  Furthermore, I don't think this is a very good graph in that pregnancy weight gain is anything but linear!  For instance, toward the end of pregnancy, often in weeks 38-40, women report a tendency not to gain any weight. 
    • Chestnut is not as active as Camille was when she was in-utero in that he isn't constantly on the move.  But I feel that his kicks are stronger.  Especially when he kicks my bladder!
    • There were a couple of nights that I had a very hard time sleeping through the hip pain.  Wednesday night was one of those nights.  I was almost in tears every time I had to turn from side to side.
    • More people are open to asking, "So when are you due?" this week.  I guess I'm very, very obviously pregnant.
    • If you are a woman or a male child under the age of 10, you can feel free to come up to me and rub my belly without asking.  I fully give you permission to do that.  Don't expect this of all pregnant women, I'm just saying it's okay for me.  If you are not a woman or a little boy, please ask me first. :)
    Spiritual & emotional:
    • My Spring Break has been blissful!  I scheduled one play date after another.  Camille had a great time hanging out with friends and cousins.  I went out to lunch with people and had friends over for dinner.  I got to finish a craft project.  I even got in a couple of naps.  *aaaaah* :)
    • There was one day that Camille missed her nap entirely (Tuesday) and even managed to climb out of her crib.  I was so frustrated that I wanted to stab my eye with a fork.  But it ended up being fine.  Have I mentioned that I love Camille a lot.  I love her a lot!!!
    Click here to see the comparison to my pregnancy with Camille (MacNut) at the same gestational age.

    Saturday, March 17, 2012

    Portland

    Up late
    We are in Portland this weekend.  I drove down with Camille Friday afternoon so we could attend her cousin Donovan's 2nd birthday party...and will drive back up Saturday night after picking up Grandma & Grandpa Ng along the way.  It's a lot of driving for under 36 hours.

    Here are pictures of Camille up late at night tonight (10pm) because she was too excited to mess around at my parents' house.

    It's alright, at least it's my Spring Break!

    Friday, March 16, 2012

    Chestnut Week 23

    If I look tired,
    then that's accurate

    Technically, this is what's going on this week:
    • Chestnut is the weight of a large mango - ~ 11.38 inches and 1.10 pounds.  (Woot woot!  Passed the 1-pound mark!)
    • The eyebrows are visible.
    • The child can successfully suck.
    • Bones located in the middle ear harden (the incus, the malleus, the umbo...possibly the cutest named body parts). He turns from side to side and head over heels. Thanks to a fully developed inner ear, which controls balance, baby may have a sense of whether he is upside-down or right side up in the womb. 
    • Skin pigment is now forming. The fetus is now proportioned like a newborn except it is a thinner version of a newborn baby since its baby fat has not developed much yet. 
    • The pancreas, essential in the production of hormones, is developing steadily. Baby has begun producing insulin, important for the breakdown of sugars.
    • If born now, he would have a 20% chance of survival, the odds going up with each passing day.
    Physical:

    • Weight: 131 lb (+18) - it's true.  I am this heavy now.
    • Belly circumference: 37.0 in (+8.5)
    • I often feel him in the evening and at night when I'm trying to fall asleep.  His movements are more visible - turning my belly lopsided, bony extremities going across my belly button, etc.  He also likes to kick my bladder a lot!
    • I'd been having definite highs and lows in energy level this week.  I think I have been running on adrenaline a lot of the time with the rush of studying for finals (believe it or not, I do enjoy the studying!).  Been getting to bed really late every night.  The earliest I went to bed this week was probably 12:45am...and the latest was 5:30am. I'm pooped.
    • I've been eating a lot.  So much.  But I've gotten Invisalign orthodontia so it's always annoying to have to remove the braces to eat or drink anything other than water.  I think the braces will help me regulate my eating more.  Hopefully.  Because I'm gaining a whole lot of weight!
    Spiritual & emotional:
    • This week has been hard.  No denying it.  My deepest frustration has been with Chin.  I have been going crazy trying to study for these finals (and random "please resubmit" assignments that keep popping up) and I have been feeling a sense of entitlement for help.  On Wednesday, the eve of my last final, I just about had it and wrote him an email explaining how I was feeling.  It was very cathartic.  For me, writing helps my mind slow down and process methodically.  That doesn't happen a lot.  Anyhow, the email was well-received and we are on good terms now.
    • It makes me proud to be able to watch Camille grow up.  She is affectionate and smart in surprising ways.  A few weeks ago, we were at a restaurant and she was demanding some of our food.  Chin said, "It's still really hot, Honey.  Can you be patient?"  And she held up her little index fingers and said, "Wait!"  She's putting concepts together (calling things "heavy" when she suspects that they might be heavy) and generating answers for more abstract questions (like "What color is the sky?" or "What color is Cookie Monster?").  I am so happy to be her mom.
    •  Guess what, this is the start of my Spring Break!  I'm pretty stoked.  No plans except for trying to set up various times to catch up with friends.  I'm looking forward to some rest.
    Click here to see the comparison to my pregnancy with Camille (MacNut) at the same gestational age.